yak(boundary-repo-as-sibling-boundary-web-repo-forbidden-tgrc): boundary: Repo as sibling boundary, web->Repo forbidden

app/lib/firehose.ex

@@ -1,4 +1,8 @@
 defmodule Firehose do
+  use Boundary,
+    deps: [Firehose.Repo],
+    exports: :all
+
   @moduledoc """
   Firehose keeps the contexts that define your domain
   and business logic.

app/lib/firehose/application.ex

@@ -3,6 +3,16 @@ defmodule Firehose.Application do
   # for more information on OTP Applications
   @moduledoc false
 
+  # Booting the app is the one job that must reach into the web tier (it starts
+  # FirehoseWeb.Telemetry and FirehoseWeb.Endpoint) while the web tier reaches
+  # back into the contexts. Declaring the Application a top-level boundary of
+  # its own is the layout boundary's README prescribes for `mix phx.new`
+  # projects, and it keeps the graph acyclic:
+  # Firehose.Application -> {Firehose, FirehoseWeb} -> Firehose -> Firehose.Repo.
+  # Putting FirehoseWeb in Firehose's deps instead is a cycle, which boundary
+  # rejects ("dependency cycle found: Firehose -> FirehoseWeb -> Firehose").
+  use Boundary, top_level?: true, deps: [Firehose, FirehoseWeb]
+
   use Application
 
   @impl true

app/lib/firehose/repo.ex

@@ -1,4 +1,6 @@
 defmodule Firehose.Repo do
+  use Boundary, top_level?: true, deps: [], exports: []
+
   use Ecto.Repo,
     otp_app: :firehose,
     adapter: Ecto.Adapters.Postgres

app/lib/firehose_web.ex

@@ -1,4 +1,8 @@
 defmodule FirehoseWeb do
+  use Boundary,
+    deps: [Firehose],
+    exports: [Endpoint, Telemetry]
+
   @moduledoc """
   The entrypoint for defining your web interface, such
   as controllers, components, channels, and so on.

app/mix.exs

@@ -11,7 +11,7 @@ defmodule Firehose.MixProject do
       aliases: aliases(),
       deps: deps(),
       test_coverage: test_coverage(),
-      compilers: [:phoenix_live_view] ++ Mix.compilers(),
+      compilers: extra_compilers(Mix.env()) ++ [:phoenix_live_view] ++ Mix.compilers(),
       listeners: [Phoenix.CodeReloader]
     ]
   end
@@ -44,6 +44,14 @@ defmodule Firehose.MixProject do
   defp elixirc_paths(:test), do: ["lib", "test/support"]
   defp elixirc_paths(_), do: ["lib"]
 
+  # The boundary compiler must be listed *before* `:elixir`: it enforces by
+  # registering an `after_compiler(:elixir, ...)` callback, so a later position
+  # would look wired and report nothing. It stays out of `:prod` on boundary's
+  # own advice (a violation must not be able to fail a release build); `:dev`
+  # and `:test` are where code is written.
+  defp extra_compilers(env) when env in [:dev, :test], do: [:boundary]
+  defp extra_compilers(_), do: []
+
   # Specifies your project dependencies.
   #
   # Type `mix help deps` for examples and options.
@@ -81,6 +89,11 @@ defmodule Firehose.MixProject do
       {:microprints,
        git: "https://gitea.apps.sustainabledelivery.com/QWAN/microprints-phoenix.git",
        branch: "main"},
+      # Compile-time boundary enforcement (Firehose / FirehoseWeb / Firehose.Repo).
+      # Declared directly even though `ex_crap` already pulls it in transitively:
+      # dropping a test-only metric tool must not silently take the boundary
+      # compiler with it.
+      {:boundary, "~> 0.11", runtime: false},
       {:credo, "~> 1.7", only: [:dev, :test], runtime: false},
       {:ex_crap, "~> 0.1.1", only: [:dev, :test], runtime: false},
       {:muex, "~> 0.12", only: [:dev, :test], runtime: false},

app/test/firehose/boundary_test.exs

@@ -0,0 +1,98 @@
+defmodule Firehose.BoundaryTest do
+  use ExUnit.Case, async: true
+
+  alias Mix.Dep.Lock
+
+  # Boundary enforcement itself is a compile-time property: the pin on it is the
+  # warnings-fatal compile in `make verify` (and the recorded violation
+  # demonstration in the yak notes). These tests pin the *declarations* that
+  # compile gate reads, so a later edit that quietly re-opens the web -> Repo
+  # hole shows up as a failure here instead of only as an architectural drift.
+  #
+  # They read the `Boundary` module attribute that `use Boundary` persists. That
+  # is the same attribute boundary's own classifier reads
+  # (deps/boundary/lib/boundary/definition.ex: `Module.register_attribute(...,
+  # Boundary, persist: true)`), so this is the declaration as compiled, not a
+  # grep of the source text.
+  describe "boundary dependency" do
+    test "boundary is a direct dependency, not one inherited from ex_crap" do
+      assert {:boundary, requirement, opts} =
+               List.keyfind(Mix.Project.config()[:deps], :boundary, 0)
+
+      assert opts[:runtime] == false, "boundary is compile-time only; it must not ship at runtime"
+      assert Version.match?(locked_version(:boundary), requirement)
+    end
+  end
+
+  describe "a sibling Repo boundary" do
+    test "Firehose.Repo is its own top-level boundary with no dependencies" do
+      definition = boundary(Firehose.Repo)
+
+      assert definition.opts[:top_level?] == true,
+             "Firehose.Repo must be a sibling of Firehose/FirehoseWeb, not nested inside Firehose"
+
+      assert deps(Firehose.Repo) == [],
+             "the Repo is the bottom of the graph: it may depend on nothing"
+    end
+
+    test "Firehose may use Firehose.Repo" do
+      assert Firehose.Repo in deps(Firehose)
+    end
+
+    test "FirehoseWeb may not use Firehose.Repo" do
+      refute Firehose.Repo in deps(FirehoseWeb),
+             "web -> Repo is the hole this boundary closes; only contexts may touch the Repo"
+    end
+  end
+
+  describe "the context boundary's surface" do
+    test "Firehose exports everything, so the web tier can keep using context modules" do
+      assert boundary(Firehose).opts[:exports] == :all
+    end
+  end
+
+  # Application boot is the only thing that reaches from the context tier into
+  # the web tier. Making it its own top-level boundary (boundary's README
+  # prescribes exactly this for `mix phx.new` layouts) is what keeps the graph
+  # acyclic; the alternative -- FirehoseWeb in Firehose's deps -- is rejected by
+  # boundary with "dependency cycle found: Firehose -> FirehoseWeb -> Firehose".
+  describe "the application boundary" do
+    test "Firehose.Application depends on both tiers, and neither tier on the other's boot code" do
+      assert boundary(Firehose.Application).opts[:top_level?] == true
+
+      assert Enum.sort(deps(Firehose.Application)) == [Firehose, FirehoseWeb]
+
+      refute FirehoseWeb in deps(Firehose),
+             "Firehose depending on FirehoseWeb is the dependency cycle"
+    end
+  end
+
+  describe "enforcement wiring" do
+    # A compiler that is registered after :elixir looks wired but never reports
+    # anything, so the gate would be decoration. Position is the property.
+    test "the boundary compiler runs before :elixir in this environment" do
+      compilers = Mix.Project.config()[:compilers]
+
+      assert :boundary in compilers, "boundary compiler is not wired in #{Mix.env()}"
+
+      assert Enum.find_index(compilers, &(&1 == :boundary)) <
+               Enum.find_index(compilers, &(&1 == :elixir)),
+             "boundary must be listed before :elixir: it hooks after_compiler(:elixir, ...)"
+    end
+  end
+
+  defp boundary(module) do
+    assert [definition] = module.__info__(:attributes)[Boundary],
+           "#{inspect(module)} declares no boundary"
+
+    definition
+  end
+
+  defp deps(module), do: Keyword.get(boundary(module).opts, :deps, [])
+
+  defp locked_version(app) do
+    Lock.read()
+    |> Map.fetch!(app)
+    |> elem(2)
+  end
+end

blogex/mix.exs

@@ -46,6 +46,10 @@ defmodule Blogex.MixProject do
       {:phoenix_live_view, "~> 1.0"},
       {:jason, "~> 1.4"},
       {:plug, "~> 1.15"},
+      # Declared directly although unused today (no boundaries, no compiler
+      # entry): `ex_crap` supplies boundary transitively, and a compile-time
+      # tool must not arrive or vanish as a side effect of a metric tool.
+      {:boundary, "~> 0.11", runtime: false},
       {:ex_doc, "~> 0.34", only: :dev, runtime: false},
       {:rustler, "~> 0.38.0", optional: true},
       {:ex_crap, "~> 0.1.1", only: [:dev, :test], runtime: false},

blogex/test/blogex/boundary_dependency_test.exs

@@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
+defmodule Blogex.BoundaryDependencyTest do
+  use ExUnit.Case, async: true
+
+  alias Mix.Dep.Lock
+
+  # blogex declares no boundaries and does not run the boundary compiler, so
+  # this dependency is inert today. It is declared directly anyway (app/mix.exs
+  # does the same) so the compiler cannot arrive or vanish as a side effect of
+  # `ex_crap`, which supplies it transitively. This pins "direct, and locked to a
+  # version that satisfies the requirement"; if boundary is ever wired up here,
+  # the compile gate is that change's pin, not this test.
+  describe "boundary dependency" do
+    test "boundary is a direct dependency, not one inherited from ex_crap" do
+      assert {:boundary, requirement, opts} =
+               List.keyfind(Mix.Project.config()[:deps], :boundary, 0)
+
+      assert opts[:runtime] == false, "boundary is compile-time only; it must not ship at runtime"
+      assert Version.match?(locked_version(:boundary), requirement)
+    end
+  end
+
+  defp locked_version(app) do
+    Lock.read()
+    |> Map.fetch!(app)
+    |> elem(2)
+  end
+end